What kind of support is right for me?

You know something needs to change, but you're not quite sure what - or how to go about it.
Perhaps you're feeling stuck in your career, questioning what you want from the next chapter of your life, or finding it difficult to make sense of something that's happened.
Deep down, you know you'd benefit from talking to someone, but what kind of support would be most helpful?
Should you speak to a coach? Find a mentor? Look for a counsellor or therapist?
They're all forms of support, but they do different things. Understanding the differences can help you work out where to start.
Coaching, mentoring, counselling or therapy: what's the difference?
If you've broken your leg, you wouldn't go to a dentist. You'd look for someone with the right skills and experience to help with the problem.
It should be much the same when it comes to seeking this kind of support. The important thing is matching the type of help to what you're experiencing and what you'd like to achieve.
Here's a simple way of thinking about the four main approaches:
If you're looking to... | You might consider... |
Work out what you want and how to move forward | Coaching |
Learn from someone who's been there | Mentoring |
Make sense of difficult feelings or experiences | Counselling |
Address more persistent or complex psychological difficulties | Therapy |
Let's look at each of these in a little more detail:
Coaching: working out what you want and how to get there
Coaching is often a good fit when you want to make changes but aren't quite sure what those changes look like or how to go about them.
Perhaps you're questioning whether you're in the right job. Maybe you've spent years putting other people first and are starting to wonder what you want for yourself. Or perhaps life is generally okay, but you have a feeling there's more you want from it.
You might find yourself asking questions like:
Is this really what I want to be doing?
What do I want the next 10 or 15 years to look like?
Why do I feel stuck?
What would make my life feel more fulfilling?
What do I need to do differently?
A coach gives you time and space to think these things through. They ask questions, challenge your thinking, help you explore options and support you to identify practical steps. They can also help you stay accountable for taking action.
The aim isn't for the coach to tell you how to live your life (I used to think this is what a life coach did!). It's to help you work out what's important to you and what you want to do about it.
Coaching tends to be forward-looking, although understanding what's happened in the past can help you make sense of where you are now.
An exercise I often use with clients is 'Your Story', which encourages them to look back on their lives and reflect on achievements, experiences and key milestones. It can bring out some fascinating insights that we often return to later in the coaching process.
And you don't need to be unhappy or in crisis to benefit from coaching. Sometimes you simply want to stop, take stock and make some more deliberate decisions about what comes next.
Mentoring: learning from someone who's been there
Although mentoring is often mentioned in the same breath as coaching, the approach is a little different.
With mentoring, you're usually looking for someone with relevant experience who can share their knowledge, offer advice and help you navigate a particular situation.
For example, you might be thinking about changing careers, moving into a leadership role or starting a business. Speaking to someone who's done something similar could help you understand what's involved and avoid some common mistakes.
A mentor can share what worked for them, what didn't, and what they might do differently with the benefit of hindsight. That experience can be incredibly useful.
When I worked at The FA, I was both a mentor and a mentee as part of an internal mentoring programme. I found both experiences positive and beneficial.
It was through subsequently training as a coach that I began to appreciate the difference between the two approaches.
As a mentor, I was often asked for advice and could draw on my own experiences. As a coach, my role is different: rather than offering answers, I help someone find their own.
The important thing to remember with mentoring is that everyone is different. What worked for someone else won't necessarily be right for you. Their role is to offer perspective and guidance, while you decide what makes sense for your own circumstances.
Counselling: making sense of what you're experiencing
Sometimes, the main issue isn't working out what you want to do next. It's understanding what you're feeling and dealing with something that's happened or is currently happening in your life.
Perhaps you're going through a relationship breakdown, dealing with bereavement, redundancy or job loss, struggling with stress, or finding it difficult to come to terms with a particular experience.
You might not fully understand why you're feeling the way you do. You may simply need somewhere to talk openly about what's going on.
Counselling provides a supportive space to explore your thoughts and feelings, make sense of your experiences and consider how you want to deal with them.
It isn't necessarily about dwelling on the past. It can help you understand what's happening now and find ways to move forward.
I experienced counselling myself a few years ago, when I was going through a difficult period in my personal life. I found it quite different from coaching and mentoring. There was much more emphasis on exploring my feelings, emotions and past experiences, and understanding how these were affecting me at the time.
It was a valuable experience that helped me move forward and gave me a greater appreciation of the different ways in which professional support can help.
Therapy: when you need more specialist support
Therapy is a broad term covering a range of approaches, including psychotherapy and specific psychological therapies such as Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT).
Depending on the type of therapy and the practitioner's training, it can help people work through persistent emotional difficulties, the effects of trauma, distressing patterns of behaviour and mental health conditions.
If you're experiencing significant anxiety, persistent low mood or other difficulties that are affecting your everyday life, it may be worth speaking to your GP or an appropriately qualified mental health professional about the support available.
It should also be noted that counselling and therapy aren't always entirely separate disciplines. The terms are sometimes used interchangeably, and there can be considerable overlap in the approaches practitioners use.
The important thing is finding someone with the right qualifications, experience and approach for what you're dealing with.
There's no shame in seeking this kind of help, and you don't have to wait until things become unbearable before doing so.
It's also worth remembering that coaching and therapy aren't opposites. Both can help people move forward, but they have different purposes.
Coaching isn't a substitute for specialist mental health support when that's what's needed.
I'm very clear that if I can't help someone as a coach, I'll do my best to signpost them to someone who can.
So, how do you know which is right for you?
This is where things can become a little less clearcut. There can be some overlap between the different approaches, and sometimes a combination of support is what's needed.
For example:
Coaching could help you explore what you want from your career and life, consider your options and decide what to do next.
Mentoring could be useful if you're looking for advice from someone with experience in the area you're working in or interested in.
Counselling could help you work through a difficult life experience or understand feelings you're struggling with.
Therapy may be more appropriate if you're experiencing persistent psychological difficulties or mental health concerns that need specialist support.
Two people can find themselves in very similar circumstances but need quite different types of support.
If you're unsure where to start, it might help to ask yourself a few questions:
What's prompted me to seek support now?
Has something happened recently? Have things been building up for a while? Or have I reached a point where I want something to change?
What do I actually want help with?
Am I looking for advice from someone with experience? Do I want to work out what I want and how to get there? Or do I need help understanding and dealing with something that's affecting my wellbeing?
How is this affecting my life?
Is it something I'm thinking about from time to time, or is it having a significant impact on my mood, relationships, work or everyday life?
Who is best placed to help me?
Think about the person's training, experience and approach. Ask questions before committing, and don't be afraid to ask whether they think their service is right for you.
A good practitioner should be honest about what they can help with and recognise when someone would be better served by a different form of support.
One thing I come across in my work is men who know something isn't quite right, but aren't sure what to do about it. You don't have to work it out on your own.
There's nothing wrong with trying to solve problems yourself. But sometimes, talking to someone with the right skills and experience can help you see things differently and work out what to do next.
You don't need to be in crisis to ask for help, and you don't need to have all the answers before you start.
What about coaching?
In my coaching work, I support men in midlife, athletes and leaders in sport who want to take stock of where they are, work out what's important to them and think about what they want from the next chapter.
That might involve career decisions, relationships, purpose, confidence or simply a feeling that life could be different.
Our first conversation is an opportunity to talk about what's going on, what you're hoping to get from support and whether coaching is likely to be a good fit.
If it is, we can explore what working together might look like. If another form of support would be more appropriate, it's important to recognise that too.
Sometimes, the first step is simply talking things through.
If you'd like to explore whether coaching might be helpful for you, feel free to drop me a line at darren@frontfootcoaching.com
Further reading
If you'd like to explore the different approaches in more detail, these resources are useful starting points:




Comments